Thread: Microsoft Security Essentials

While it was still in beta as of this writing, Microsoft Security Essentials shows promise: In our tests it was decent at detecting malware, particularly in proactive tests. The main draw-back of the tool, which will launch by year's end, seemed to be its slow scan speed.

Since Microsoft says the tool is feature-complete and simply undergoing fine-tuning now (and since it had a limited public beta release in early summer), we decided to test it and rank it alongside the other apps. Keep in mind, though, that its performance may change before its final release.

One thing we hope will change is its relatively poky scan speed. It was the slowest in our on-access scan test, which judges how quickly scans run when you copy, open, or save files. The app's Dynamic Signature Service may account for some of that: When Security Essentials sees a potentially bad file that doesn't match known malware, it contacts Microsoft servers for additional analysis. The feature likely affords greater protection, but it may also introduce some delay if Security Essentials has to wait for a response.

The app's ability to detect and block malware was neither especially good nor particularly bad. Its 97.8 percent overall detection rate put it in fourth; but it did well in proactive tests, which use two- and four-week-old signatures to simulate detecting new, unknown malware. Its results of 52 percent and 43.8 percent, respectively, were second only to those of the top-ranked Avira.

Microsoft's program put up no false positives, and it got a near-perfect score overall in detecting and cleaning rootkits and malware infections. It detected and disabled every infection, and although it left behind changes to the Registry and other areas (as every free app did), they couldn't cause further harm.

Security Essentials has a pleasing interface, is simple to use, and has appropriate defaults. Its pop-ups let you deal with an issue quickly or dig in for details. If Microsoft can improve the detection and rev up the scan speed before the final release, Security Essentials could turn out to be a real contender.